Welcome

Anti Essays offers essay examples to help students with their essay writing.

Sign Up

Henry Mintzberg Considers the Image of Management Which Has Developed from the Work of Henri Fayol as One of Folklore Rather Than Fact. However, It Could Be Argued That the Image Portrayed by Fayol Is Superior to That Essay

Open Document

Below is an essay on "Henry Mintzberg Considers the Image of Management Which Has Developed from the Work of Henri Fayol as One of Folklore Rather Than Fact. However, It Could Be Argued That the Image Portrayed by Fayol Is Superior to That" from Anti Essays, your source for research papers, essays, and term paper examples.

‘Management’ is a generalized term used since the beginning of the 20th century to describe managing organisations. Throughout these years, several scholars, scientists and researchers have all attempted to define what exactly management is, what it entails and how exactly effective management comes about.
Henri Fayol, of the Classical school of thought, is considered a forerunner of the study of management. Much of his work provides a basis upon which other writers expand or criticise; one of the most notable writers being Henry Mintzberg from the Empirical school of thought. Mintzberg’s work and research is often considered a more modern and contemporary approach to management, as he develops and expands it but also criticises Fayol’s classical principles of management (1916). Mintzberg argues, as the title would give away in his article written in 1975, that Fayol’s principles and the image of management developed from them are actually of “Folklore”, not “Fact”.
Although they are both from different schools of thought, it is to be taken into account that both writers have some very similar ideas, as well as some very different ideas. It is also to be considered that they both have their own strengths and weaknesses.

One evident difference between the two writers is that Fayol writes the majority of his work in a prescriptive manner, explaining how things should be done. For example, Fayol’s principles of management (1916) name fourteen terms for what is necessary to be an effective manager.   It is extremely projective, almost like a target to aim towards. On the other hand, Mintzberg writes in an extremely descriptive style. His studies in the article “The Manager’s Job: Folklore and Fact” (1975), describe what is happening, giving an account of what the manager actually does.
A problem that arises with Fayol’s description is that it is often considered a mere projection of the perfect manager; almost an idea of what somebody would hope their job as a...

Show More


Citations

MLA Citation

"Henry Mintzberg Considers the Image of Management Which Has Developed from the Work of Henri Fayol as One of Folklore Rather Than Fact. However, It Could Be Argued That the Image Portrayed by Fayol Is Superior to That". Anti Essays. 11 Dec. 2018

<http://trenmayamx.com/free-essays/Henry-Mintzberg-Considers-The-Image-Of-604007.html>

APA Citation

Henry Mintzberg Considers the Image of Management Which Has Developed from the Work of Henri Fayol as One of Folklore Rather Than Fact. However, It Could Be Argued That the Image Portrayed by Fayol Is Superior to That. Anti Essays. Retrieved December 11, 2018, from the World Wide Web: http://trenmayamx.com/free-essays/Henry-Mintzberg-Considers-The-Image-Of-604007.html